When a note counts as non-performing
A note is non-performing when the payer has stopped paying or has fallen well behind. One late payment does not put a note in this category, but a string of missed payments does, and where the line falls for a non-performing note is not the same for every buyer.
The term describes the status of the payments, which is separate from the collateral and lien position that define the other types of notes you can sell. A first-lien mortgage, a land contract or a second can each be performing one year and non-performing the next. If the payer catches up and stays caught up, the note is called re-performing.
How the pricing changes
A performing note is priced on its payments. A buyer adds up what is due, discounts it at the return they need, and arrives at a price.
When payments stop, the schedule can no longer be trusted and that method fails. The buyer turns to the collateral and asks different questions.
- What is the property worth today, in its present condition?
- Is anyone living there, and are they looking after it?
- What is owed ahead of the note, such as unpaid property taxes?
- What would it cost, and how long would it take, to recover the property in that state?
- Is there a realistic chance the payer will start paying again?
The price is what is left after those costs and risks, plus a return for the buyer’s time and work. That is why the discount is deeper than on a performing note, and why a large balance on a property worth little does not produce a large price.
Sell, or enforce it yourself
Selling is one of three routes, and an honest comparison includes the other two.
The first is to work it out with the payer. If they have hit a temporary problem, a written repayment plan may restore the note.
The second is to enforce the note: foreclose, or cancel a land contract where the law allows, and take the property back. You may end up with more than a sale would bring. You also carry the legal costs, the delay, and the taxes and insurance in the meantime.
The third is to sell: a known amount now, with the work and the uncertainty passed to someone equipped for it. You can only weigh that route with a number in front of you, so send us the details of the note and set what comes back beside a foreclosure attorney’s estimate of what enforcing it yourself would cost.
Which is best depends on the equity in the property, your own finances and how much of this you want to manage. We compare the two main routes in should I sell the note or foreclose.
While you decide
Delay has a cost of its own. Unpaid taxes build up, insurance lapses and an empty property declines, so a default that is a few months old leaves a buyer more to work with than one that has run for years.
Be careful what you accept from the payer in the meantime. Taking a part payment, or agreeing new terms informally, can affect your rights, so speak to an attorney before you change anything.
If the payer has filed for bankruptcy, collection is generally paused by the court. The note can often still be sold, though to a smaller group of buyers, and they will need to know about the filing from the outset.
The facts a buyer will ask for
Write down the date of the last payment, the amount now overdue, and what you know about the property and who is in it. Add whether the property taxes and the insurance are paid up, and keep copies of any letters you have sent the payer about the default. A buyer prices what can be shown, and on a note that has stopped paying, a dated record of what happened is most of what there is to show.